Welcome Guest Login or Signup
LIVE CHAT | INSTANT MESSENGER | BOOKMARK US | LANGUAGE:
 

BLOGS   WRITE NEW BLOG   EDIT BLOGS  
 
RSS
A Challenge
Posted On 18/05/2008 22:05:56 by LoloRay

Ok. Right. How about we all do this - I challenge you all to, for a week, actually leave an honest comment on the pictures and images you don't like, don't particularly like, or see room for improvement.

Rules: Be honest and give useful detailed feedback. Don't be mean.

This way, I think we all could learn from eachother, if we see what is wrong with the images. New TOGs and models are going to learn nothing from people saying positive things about crappy images - not to mention people with more experience.

If it doesn't work, then we can all revert to the old way of only commenting on good images (which is what I usually unless I know the person or have been asked for my opinion), or leaving complementary comments on images that are blatantly crap.

Thoughts? Leave a message if you actually do this this week.

To make it easy, you can start with my images. I'm bracing myself!

Tags: Challenge Photos Images Comment Critisise






Viewing 1 - 2 out of 2 Comments

19/05/2008 21:19:14

I'm with Frankie on this - there are too many sensitive egos on here that are liable to take offence at the slightest negative comment about their work. I'll continue to limit my critique to those photographers I know will not take offence. If someone I don't know well invites me to give my opinion on their work, I will do so privately.


- Thorsten.



19/05/2008 17:13:03

It is what I have always done, yes I am blunt but I never mean to be rude although people take it like that. I give as many good comments as bad. Unfortunately a lot of people can't take other people perspectives on board, I am not saying I am right you are wrong, when I critique you I am merely giving MY opinion. Good Luck with this I think a few people's noses will be put out of joint LOL





*** folio32.com ***